DON’T “just do it”.

Roybox…. Before I start the article a little “back story”. People have been asking me why I stopped writing and my reply is there is SO much written with Facebook, etc. that seems there is overload with training information.  Then someone said something to me that struck a chord. Their comment was – it isn’t just the training information they get from my articles but I encourage them to think (which just happens to be one of my favorite things to do — and that did get me thinking). I do try and give more ideas on how to communicate with your dog rather than — here is HOW to train your dog. Anyway, back to the article…

‘Don’t “just do it”!

           Niki’s saying has a lot of merits but I don’t think it is conducive to shaping a sensible working dog. Doing “it” without thought creates action but does not produce thoughtful work or useful results. 

The more dogs I train the more I appreciate ability blended with a calm mind. I think this is the best combination for a top working dog. I find one of the hardest ones to train is the gifted ones with talent but they “trip” over their own mind. They can’t calm their mind down enough to hear the information you’re offering or read what the sheep are needing.  If he is of this “type” the more he works the faster his mind operates without actually thinking. So, his every “thought” turns into a physical response. (I tend to compare it to people that have anxiety and get so “agitated” they have difficulty functioning. I think this applies to dogs as well.) What makes that “type” so difficult to train, is getting your correction and release timing perfectly accurate. Your correction needs to be applied when he’s thinking of doing something wrong. However, he’s so busy reacting that his body might be doing one thing but his mind is somewhere else. 

The mind/body connection is so great that having one that is calm minded greatly amplifies training. I used to think it was tension but now believe a dog can be tense but still hear and respond to training. Just like some people are tense but can get the job done – because their mind has the ability to absorb information quickly and stay focused. Their body may lean towards tension but the mind stays open to information.

SO – what can you do to help develop a calm minded thinking dog?

As with everything it originates in the beginning stages of training. So if you are having working issues go back to the basics and correct the holes you have in your basic training. You need to teach your dog not only the things he’s expected to respond to but also what he’s NOT supposed to react to. This applies to not only when you are working sheep but just as much when he’s not working. Body language is the first way a dog learns. When a dog is reacting to your body pressure you put a word with it. Then you stop using your body when you see his response is automatic so your “body clues” are no longer needed. If you don’t have consistent body language it often creates anxiety – never allowing the dog to understand what is expected of him. If you aren’t consistent with your interactions with him off sheep …  then expect him to comprehend what you require simply because you are working sheep – it can produce a major struggle in his mind.

I try to teach a dog how to solve problems on his own – but I’m always there to help him accomplish it. You don’t give him the answers – you allow him to find them – then reward him. To do this you have to be predictable. They need to feel that once they find the answer they can control what’s going to happen next. You need them mentally and physically balanced. Where he’s relaxed in his mind but can produce an immediate physical response. So, if you allow him to be “hyper” in everyday life but expect calm and collected while working, you will have a difficult time achieving that state.

That’s one of the reasons for a down during training. It’s not a punishment! It’s a system to let him collect, calm and correct himself in order to find answers. It can be employed to calm his mind BUT if NOT done correctly it will just make him tenser. You need to let him figure out that once he’s down, he has a chance to understand what you are asking, what the sheep need and what he has to do to accomplish both. HOW you go about asking is something people don’t think enough about and should. The dog can’t think a correction is just a random act. They need to know they are the ones that have control over when a correction “goes away”. This is what provides them the initiative to learn to solve problems. 

So, you need to work on your relationship before you move on to livestock training. You need him aware of you and what you need. Corrections are not used to shut him down or totally control him – but are needed to help him connect with you. Responsive when asked – relaxed when needed. You need to work on timing and communication of your pressure on/off — so he comes back from a correction reflecting instead of reacting. It’s just as important off sheep as it is on.


15 Comments Add yours

  1. Janice says:

    Great article, thank you. Information I needed.

  2. Vivien Hastert says:

    Thank you for your Article. I love the common sense kind of training. I am looking forward to more.

    1. Thanks – I’ll try and update more often.

  3. Susan Cooper says:

    I am loving your writings. I have one of those “deaf” border collies that is so intense, he doesn’t hear me. After a year of working on this, he finally has acknowledged my presence and the past year of training him mechanically has led to a dog that is now thinking and reacting properly. It’s tough when your first BC is a hard nut to crack. Trial by fire for me, but oh, I’m learning so much along the way! And the journey and training is the part I enjoy the most. The getting into the dog’s mind and that communication!

    1. Makes it all worthwhile when they finally get it!

  4. Jessica K. Taylor says:

    I started getting this lady’s emails when I bought Brooke and Blaze. She is very good and this applies to all dogs.

    From: Training Border Collies Reply-To: Training Border Collies Date: Sunday, February 9, 2020 at 7:08 AM To: Subject: [New post] DON’T “just do it”.

    Candy Kennedy posted: ” …. Before I start the article a little “back story”. People have been asking me why I stopped writing and my reply is there is SO much written with Facebook, etc. that seems there is overload with training information. Then someone said some”

    1. Thanks – always good to hear.

  5. Sue Main says:

    Hi Candy. A great thought provoking article as usual. I so miss my chats with GWYN and reading this took me back to where we would discuss and analyse, not only our dogs but ourselves.
    In relation to the ‘calm dog’ I recall many years ago before our dogs were kept in pens and were chained up, he said at the time that he had found his dogs to be calmer if they were tied up. This of course was only when not out and working. I recall thinking how calm his dogs were compared to mine. Saying that while he was out doing jobs, his dogs would always be with him, at least his main dogs. His personality and attitude also had a calming influence on them and he was of the opinion like you, that they would learn and think
    better when they were calm. A dog full of adrenaline and tension would not be as receptive to training or thinking than a calm dog.
    I also believe that work plays a big part in achieving calmness.
    Love your articles. Thank you for encouraging me to think and analyse again.

  6. I miss him too (and you 😊 ) …. all of us discussing our thoughts of the how and whys of training. We had some great conversations! I saw you had a new dog and
    doing well. Happy for you.

  7. Karen says:

    I have a border collie that I do agility with. I work her on equipment and she is barking and cannot think she is so excited. I am not sure where to start with her. Do I rename all obstacles when working with her, not sure where to go from here.

    1. Sorry, I have never tried agility so can’t be much help.

  8. Anna says:

    Thank you, Candy, for this. I love reading training articles and books, and attending clinics. To me, the working and training of the dogs is the part I enjoy the most. Busy with a rather hot-headed one at present, so I will reread your writing and use the help. Thx.

    1. Glad you enjoyed it – Hope it helps!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s